When someone experiences extreme mood swings, it can be confusing to know what’s happening. Two conditions often compared—and sometimes mistaken for each other—are bipolar disorder and borderline personality disorder (BPD).
While they share some similar symptoms, such as intense mood changes, they are different mental health conditions with unique causes, diagnostic criteria, and treatment approaches. Understanding these differences is crucial for identifying the right support and effective treatment.
Understanding Bipolar Disorder
Bipolar disorder is a mood disorder that causes episodes of unusually elevated mood, energy, and activity levels (known as manic episodes) along with periods of depression. These shifts are not just “mood swings” that happen in response to life events—they are more extreme and last longer.
There are several types of bipolar disorder. Here is an overview of these conditions.
- Bipolar I disorder: Defined by at least one severe manic episode, which may be accompanied by depressive episodes.
- Bipolar II disorder: Characterized by less intense hypomanic and depressive symptoms, but the depressive episodes can be just as debilitating.
- Cyclothymic disorder: Involves long-lasting but milder mood shifts that don’t meet the full criteria for manic or depressive episodes.
These mood episodes can disrupt sleep patterns, affect relationships, and interfere with a person’s life, work, or education.
Bipolar disorder often develops in early adulthood, though it can appear in adolescence. Family history, genetic risks, and brain structure or brain differences all play a role. Stressful events, childhood trauma, and emotional neglect can also contribute to developing bipolar disorder.
Understanding Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD)
Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is part of a group of personality disorders that affect how someone thinks about themselves and others.
BPD symptoms often include:
- Intense mood swings and affective instability.
- Fear of abandonment and sensitivity to perceived rejection.
- Chaotic relationships and difficulties with boundaries.
- Self-harm, risky behaviors (including substance abuse), and struggles with emotional regulation.
- Difficulty maintaining a stable self-image.
These symptoms are not temporary. They represent patterns that profoundly impact a person’s life, particularly in relationships, work, and self-identity.
Many people with BPD report histories of childhood trauma, including sexual abuse, childhood abuse, or emotional neglect. Genetics, brain structure, and stressful events also play a role. While not everyone with these experiences develops BPD, they increase vulnerability to borderline personality traits.
Bipolar Disorder vs Borderline Personality Disorder: Key Differences
Although BPD and bipolar disorder share some similar symptoms, there are significant differences.
Here is an overview of these differences.
Nature of Mood Changes
Bipolar disorder involves longer-lasting bipolar episodes (days to weeks of mania, hypomania, or depression). BPD is marked by affective instability and rapid, extreme mood swings—sometimes shifting within hours.
Triggers
In bipolar disorder, mood episodes may occur without clear triggers. In BPD, mood changes are often tied to perceived rejection, unstable relationships, or stressful life events.
Emotional Regulation
Bipolar patients struggle with mood episodes that stem from internal brain and chemical changes. People with BPD face challenges in emotional regulation, often responding to situations with intense emotions and intense feelings.
Duration and Course
Bipolar disorder tends to follow a cyclical course over a lifetime. BPD symptoms are persistent patterns of emotional dysregulation and difficulties with managing emotions.
Self Image and Relationships
Bipolar disorder doesn’t typically affect core self-identity. BPD involves unstable self-image, frequent chaotic relationships, and intense fears of abandonment.
Common Misunderstandings
Because both conditions involve mood swings and depressive symptoms, people often confuse them. It’s also possible to live with BPD and bipolar disorder at the same time, making an accurate diagnosis even more important.
Other mental health conditions—such as major depressive disorder, anxiety disorders, and eating disorders—can overlap, along with co-occurring disorders like substance abuse. This overlap is why evaluation by trained mental health professionals is crucial.
Diagnosing Bipolar Disorder vs BPD
Bipolar disorder is diagnosed when someone meets criteria for manic episodes, hypomanic episodes, or depressive episodes, depending on the type. Borderline personality disorder is diagnosed when someone consistently shows patterns of emotional dysregulation, unstable relationships, and self-image issues.
Receiving a proper diagnosis can significantly impact a person’s treatment plan and future. Misdiagnosis may lead to ineffective treatment, which can worsen other symptoms and distress.
Treatment Approaches
Mental health conditions like bipolar disorder and borderline personality are treatable. With medications, therapies, and other evidence-based treatments, it is possible to manage the symptoms of these conditions and move forward.
The primary treatment for bipolar disorder usually combines:
- Mood stabilizers to regulate mood shifts and prevent severe manic episodes.
- Psychotherapy to manage emotional regulation and stressful events.
- Lifestyle adjustments, like improving sleep patterns and reducing substance abuse.
Treatment for BPD focuses on psychotherapy, particularly:
- Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), also known as dialectical behavioral therapy, which helps with managing emotions, emotional control, and reducing self-harm behaviors.
- Transference-focused psychotherapy, which explores patterns in relationships.
- Group therapy and support for building healthier relationships.
Medication may help with other symptoms or co-occurring conditions like anxiety disorders or major depressive disorder, but it is not the primary treatment.
Living with Bipolar Disorder or BPD
Both conditions can be overwhelming, but with the right support, individuals can effectively manage their symptoms and lead fulfilling lives. Proper treatment, including psychotherapy and sometimes medication, makes it possible to build stability.
Support from family, friends, and mental health professionals can make a significant difference in one’s life. Recognizing that these are legitimate mental illnesses and not character flaws is a vital step toward healing.
Find Treatment and Support
BPD and bipolar disorder both involve challenges like intense emotions, mood changes, and difficulties in a person’s life, but recovery is possible with compassionate care and the right treatment plan.
If you or someone you love is struggling, reach out to mental health professionals—help is available, and healing is within reach. Contact the First Step Behavioral Health specialists to learn about our comprehensive treatment and support programs or to schedule an intake appointment.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can stress alone cause bipolar disorder or borderline personality disorder?
Stressful or traumatic events can trigger symptoms or worsen existing conditions, but stress by itself does not directly cause bipolar disorder or BPD. A combination of factors, including genetics, brain differences, and early life experiences, influences both conditions. Stress may, however, play a role in when symptoms first appear or how severe they become.
2. Are bipolar disorder and BPD more common in women or men?
Research suggests that borderline personality disorder is more frequently diagnosed in women, though men may be underdiagnosed. Bipolar disorder affects men and women at roughly equal rates, but the way symptoms present can differ. For example, women with bipolar disorder are more likely to experience rapid cycling or depressive episodes.
3. Can lifestyle changes improve symptoms of bipolar disorder or BPD?
Yes. While professional treatment is essential, lifestyle adjustments can support recovery. Consistent sleep patterns, healthy nutrition, stress management, and avoiding substance abuse can reduce symptom intensity. Building supportive relationships and practicing skills learned in therapy also help stabilize emotions and prevent relapse.
4. What’s the connection between childhood experiences and these conditions?
For some individuals, childhood trauma, abuse, or neglect increases the risk of developing borderline personality disorder. In bipolar disorder, childhood experiences may act as triggers, but the underlying cause is often more strongly linked to genetic and biological factors. Both conditions can also be influenced by how individuals learn to regulate their emotions early in life.
5. Do bipolar disorder and BPD ever improve with age?
Yes, symptoms can change over time. Many people with BPD find that emotional instability lessens with age, especially with effective therapy. Bipolar disorder typically remains a lifelong condition, but with treatment, episodes may become less frequent and easier to manage. Long-term stability is possible for both with the right support.
6. How do mental health professionals tell the difference during diagnosis?
Clinicians use structured interviews, standardized assessments, and a detailed history of symptoms to distinguish between the two. They look at the timing, duration, and triggers of mood changes, as well as patterns in relationships and self-image. Because overlapping symptoms can cause confusion, accurate diagnosis often requires ongoing observation and evaluation.
Sources
Jump to a Section
Call (855) 425-4846
